Skip to main content

The "Most Complicated Thing You Could Possibly Imagine" is inside the Proton.

 An object of unfathomable complexity, the positively charged particle at the centre of the atom can change its appearance depending on how it is examined. The numerous faces of the proton have been connected to provide the most complete picture to date.

They are described as featureless balls with one unit of positive electric charge each by high school physics teachers, making them the ideal counterbalance for the positively charged electrons that whirl around them. College students discover that the ball is actually a bundle of three quarks, which are fundamental particles. However, decades of study have uncovered a more profound reality that is too odd to be adequately expressed in words or visuals.

A physicist from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology named Mike Williams declared, "This is the most difficult thing that you could ever imagine." You simply cannot comprehend how difficult it is.

The proton is a quantum mechanical object that, prior to an experiment, exists only as a cloud of probability. And depending on how researchers set up their experiment, its forms vary greatly. Generations have worked to link the particle's several faces. Nuclear physicist Richard Milner of MIT commented, "We're kind of just starting to comprehend this system completely."

The proton's secrets start coming out as the chase goes on. The proton has recently been discovered to contain remnants of particles called charm quarks that are heavier than the proton itself, according to a significant data analysis that was released in August.

According to Williams, the proton "has been humbling to mankind." "It throws you some curveballs every time you think you kind of got a grasp on it."

Recently, Milner, along with Rolf Ent at Jefferson Lab, MIT filmmakers Chris Boebel and Joe McMaster, and animator James LaPlante, set out to create a series of cartoons showing the shape-shifting proton using a set of mysterious plots that combine the findings of hundreds of trials. Their cartoons have been included into our own endeavour to discover its secrets.

Taking the Proton apart

The Stanford Linear Accelerator Center (SLAC) provided evidence in 1967 that the proton is made up of many particles. In prior tests, scientists had bombarded it with electrons and watched as they bounced off like pool balls. However, SLAC could launch electrons farther, and scientists saw that they reacted to impact differently. Through a phenomenon known as deep inelastic scattering, the electrons were striking the proton so forcefully that it broke into point-like fragments known as quarks. According to University of Virginia physicist Xiaochao Zheng, "it was the first evidence that quarks actually exist."

Following SLAC's discovery, which earned it the 1990 Nobel Prize in Physics, the proton came under closer study. Hundreds of scattering experiments have been conducted by physicists to date. They infer various aspects of the object’s interior by adjusting how forcefully they bombard it and by choosing which scattered particles they collect in the aftermath.

Physicists can extract the target proton's finer properties utilising electrons with higher energy. The greatest resolving power of a deep inelastic scattering experiment is thus determined by the electron energy. A clearer glimpse of the proton is provided by particle colliders with greater strength.

Higher-energy colliders also generate a greater range of collision results, allowing scientists to select various outgoing electron subsets for analysis. Understanding quarks, which careen around inside the proton with various levels of momentum, has proven to depend on this flexibility.

Researchers can determine whether an electron has glanced off a quark carrying a significant portion of the proton's overall momentum or just a little amount by analysing the energy and trajectory of each scattered electron. They can determine whether the proton's momentum is mostly contained in a small number of quarks or is dispersed throughout a large number of quarks by repeatedly colliding particles.

By today's standards, even the proton-splitting collisions at SLAC were mild. In such scattering occurrences, electrons frequently ejected in a manner that suggested quarks carrying a third of the proton's entire momentum had struck them. The discovery supported a notion put forth in 1964 by Murray Gell-Mann and George Zweig, who proposed that a proton is made up of three quarks.

The "quark model" developed by Gell-Mann and Zweig is still a beautiful representation of the proton. It has one "down" quark with a charge of 1/3 and two "up" quarks with electric charges of +2/3 each, giving it a total proton charge of +1.

This data-driven animation features three quarks careening around.

Jefferson Lab, MIT, and Sputnik Animation

However, the quark model is an oversimplification with significant flaws.

In the case of a proton's spin, a quantum feature similar to angular momentum, it falls short. Each of the proton's up and down quarks possesses half a unit of spin, as does the proton itself. The initial assumption made by physicists was that the half-units of the two up quarks less the half-unit of the down quark must equal half a unit for the proton as a whole in a calculation that echoed the simple charge arithmetic. 

However, the European Muon Collaboration stated in 1988 that the sum of the quark spins is much less than 0.5. Similarly, the masses of just one down quark and two up quarks consist of the entire mass of a proton. These deficiencies highlighted a concept that scientists were already beginning to understand: the proton is significantly more complex than just three quarks.


Comments